| Platinum | Rixster Grill |
| Gold | East Coast Wings + Grill |
| Silver | Pizza Wing King Family Restaurant |
| Bronze | Pizza Vino |
| Top Pick | Biscuits Brisket & Beer |
| Top Pick | Blue Rock Pizza and Tap |
| Top Pick | Christos Original |
| Top Pick | George's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Kings BBQ Burgers & More |
| Top Pick | Mario's Pizza |