| Platinum | Blue Rock Pizza and Tap |
| Gold | Pizza Vino |
| Silver | Lubrano's Pizza & Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Odeh's Mediterranean Kitchen |
| Top Pick | George's Pizza |
| Top Pick | LA-Pizzeria Inc |
| Top Pick | Mario's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza Wing King Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sir Pizza |
| Top Pick | Uncle Maddio's Pizza |