| Platinum | Sanibel's |
| Gold | The Full Moon Oyster Bar - Jamestown |
| Silver | Skipper's Seafood Restaurant |
| Bronze | Blue Water Grill |
| Top Pick | Captain Toms Seafood and Oyster Bar |
| Top Pick | Harbor One |
| Top Pick | Odeh's Mediterranean Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Sammy G's Tavern |
| Top Pick | Seafood Destiny |